ISP Logo

Ian Smith and Partners

Consulting Engineers Ltd.

HomeCompany ProfileServicesNewsProjectsContact UsStaffFeedBack

Fire Investigation Profile

Gerry Coates joined Ian Smith & Partners (ISP) in June 1998. Previously he had his own firm G L Coates Consultants Ltd that built a formidable reputation for fire and incident investigations over the years with over 250 jobs to date.

Gerry originally graduated with a postgraduate degree in 1964, and spent time in industry in UK with English Electric Co Ltd (now GEC) returning to NZ in 1967. In 1970 he joined W G Morrison & Partners (now Kingston Morrison Ltd), and started their electrical consulting division, becoming a partner in 1975. He left in 1980 to form his own firm, before joining with ISP in 1998.

 He is a Fellow of the Institution of Professional Engineers, and a founder of the group Engineers for Social Responsibility.

Over the years Gerry has handled a wide range of projects and built up a large experience base in electrical engineering and associated areas. A particular specialty is investigating and advising on incidents such as failures, fires, explosions, hazardous areas and product safety issues.

Mediations and arbitrations have also been carried out. A complete list of all investigations and arbitrations he has carried out since 1980 is given below:

The list below contains 251 cases to date. (October 1999)

 

Gerry Coates

1999
Capital Loss Adjusters - Spa pool pump fire, Hataitai
Crocombe Adjusters - Neon sign damage, Paraparaumu
GAB Robins - Hotel apartment fire (cooktop)
  " " - House fire, Eastbourne (cooktop)
  " " - Juken Nissho, Masteron (PLC fire)
  " " - Juken Nissho, Masteron (Compressor fire)
  " " - Hotel fire, Portland Towers (heater)
  " " - Dorothy Patisserie fire, Wellington
McLaren Toplis - Electrical failure, supermarket
  " " - House fire, Lower Hutt (light fitting)
  " " - Fryer fire, Porirua
  " " - Air conditioning failure, Queensgate
  " " - House fire, Glenmore St (towel rail)
  " " - Neon Sign fire, Harbour City
  " " - Switchboard fire, Ngaio Town Hall
  " " - Delicatessen fire, "Platter" Hataitai
Heaney & Co - Pacific Steel v Atlas Copco Ltd
Keegan Alexander - Baby Monitor fire
McElroys - Litigation re chiller fire (see # in 1997)
  " - Litigation re menu board fire (see # in 1994)
Philips Fox - Litigation re fryer fire (see * in 1998)
Young Hunter - Litigation re chiller fire (see * in 1997)

 

Burned out Junction Box - Click to enlarge

Burned out Junction Box

Test Rig - Click to enlarge

Test rig to measure the temperature of the Junction Box.

1998 (from June with Ian Smith & Partners)
GAB Robins - Electrolux ofice fire
  " " - UPS fire, National Library
  " " - St Francis Apartments fire
  " " - Strikeline bowling fire
  " " - Hardy St Fish and Chip shop fire
  " " - Tawa chicken grill shop fire
  " " - Electric jug as fire cause
Flinders Cook - Aro Street fire
Heaney & Co - Prestige Meats v Powernet and H & J [Settled out of court]
Jacobs Florentine - Litigation re Dannevirke stove fire
  (see ** in 1995) [Settled out of court]
Jones Fee * Tractor fire, Gore
  " " * Ongoing litigation re Case tractor fires for FMG
Jones Fee/Royal SunAlliance * Tauranga Churchill
  Building full fire investigation.
McLarens Toplis - Fire in luminaire
  " " - Opinion on fryer fire, Gisborne (*)
McElroys - Litigation re menu board fire (see # in 1994)
MMI - Tractor fire investigation, Timaru
  - Tractor fire investigation, Reporoa
Pogson Cronin, Melbourne - Litigation re header fire (see # in 1997)
NZI - Expert review of suspected arson

 

1998 (with GL Coates Consultants Ltd)
GAB Robins -Hoover dryer fire
  -Chiller unit Fire
Jones Fee * Litigation re tractor fire (see * in 1997)
  * Opinion on water cooler fire
1997
GAB Robins - Westpac switchboard reinstatement
  " " House fire, Makara
  " " House fire, Ngaio
  " " House fire, Lower Hutt (TV)
  " " West Plaza hotel laundry fire
  " " Collins cranes, fire in building crane
FMG Australia * Combine harvester fire (#)
Izard Weston * Litigation re frig fire (see * in 1994)
Jones Fee * Tractor fire, Palmerston North (*)
  " " * Tractor fire, Kaitaia
  " " * Tractor fire, Gore
  " " * Tractor fire, Gore
  " " * Tractor fire, Gore
Melco Sales * Opinion on electric kettle fire
McLarens * Shirley library fire (dishwasher) (*)
Morley Security * Suspect multi-way box
NZ Fire Investigations - Commercial Premises fire (chiller) (#)
1996
GAB Robins - Radfords retail store faulty light fire
  " " Raihia St fire (alleged facsimile cause)
Jones Fee * Tegel Foods power failure claim [Settled out of court]
Knight Frank Ltd - Mid-City centre: Switchboard fire
Land Information NZ * Lighting level investigation
Melco Sales * Opinion on electric jug fire
  " " * Opinion on TV fire
McLarens * Damaged computer equipment
Steiner School * Assistance with transmission line case.

 

1995
Robins NZ - Blenheim tractor electrical fire
" " - Housing NZ building emergency lighting fire
" " - Pinnacle St house fire
" " - Treasury computer fire in UPS
" " - Blenheim house fire (stove)
" " * Honda Civic car fire.
" " * The Open Polytech classroom fire
" " * House fire , Health Enterprise owned, Nelson
" " * Karori Golf Club fire
" " * Plastic moulding machine fire, Masterton
" " * Treasury: Fire in computer UPS
" " * House fire, Blenheim.
Porirua City Council- PCC v Mecon & Teco (settled).
Flinders Cook - Clothes dryer fire investigation, Miramar.
Crocombe Advisers - House fire, Maupuia
Heaney Jones * Tractor fire, Invercargill
  " " * Tractor fire, Palmerston North
Kensington Swan * Opinion on Jaguar XJ12 fire
McElroys * Automatic clothes washer fire investigation.
NZI - Investigation, house fire, Lower Hutt
  " - The Warehouse fire, Oamaru
M & I Consultants - ABB transformer damage
NZ Fire Investigations - Dannevirke stove fire
  Investigation (**)
Seafood Specialties - Freezer failure

 

1994
Robins NZ - Quality Inn sauna fire
  " " - Fire investigation, Tui Milk dryer
  " " - Investigation/reinstatement, Parliament cable theft
  " " - Fire investigation, farmhouse suspect refrigerator
  " " - Fire investigation, RNZAF clothes dryer
  " " - Fire invest., farmhouse suspected arson
  " " - Fire investigation Masterton refrig. (*)
  " " - Fire investigation neon sign Mischief Shoes
NZI - Fire investigation, Majoribanks St dairy
  " - Fire investigation, Mexican Supplies factory
  " - Fire investigation, Flight Andersen timber plant
  " - Fire investigation, Kambrook urn involvement
  " - Post fire investigation, Raumati spa pool
Dean Crocombe - Investigation into sprinkler failure
ECNZ - Revenue metering project progress review
Trans Power - Haywards synchronous condenser failure
NZ Fire Investigations - Wanganui video fire
" " " - Better Wear suspected radio fire
" " " - Mount Four Square fire
" " " - Suspected Glade air-freshener fire
McLarens - National Bank menuboard fire invest. (#)

1993
Robins MBS - Fire invest., McFarlane St house fire
  " " - Incident investigation, Tawa power outage
  " " - Fire investigation, Adams Print switchboard
  " " - Fire investigation, ECNZ Stratford heater fire
  " " - Fire investigation, VUW new Kohanga Reo
  " " - Forklift repair investigation
  " " - Fire reinstatement Parapine planer building
  " " - Fire investigation, Dunlop carphone fire
  " " - Fire investigation, Colgate switchboard fire
  " " - Invest./ reinstatement Courtaulds gantry collapse
  " " - Investigation/reinstatement, Lennard kiln fire
  " " - Investigation, CHB Power transformer fault
  " " - Fire investigation, Camborne house fire
  " " - Fire investigation, Trans Power HVDC reactor
  " " - Fire investigation, Levin broiler chicken factory
NZI - Fire investigation, Mana View Rd house
  " - Litigation Adelaide Rd dairy fire (see * in 1989)
  " - Investigation re Upper Hutt power outage
  " - Fire investigation Paraparaumu dairy
  " - Vehicle fire (1993 Commodore)
National Insurance - Fire invest. Lwr Hutt garage
Commercial Union - Fire investigation, sandwich maker
Rainey Collins Wright - Fire investig. re current valves
Fire & Casualty - Fire investigation, Elizabeth Street flat

 

1992
Robins MBS - Fire investigation, fish fryer
  " " - Post fire liability investigation St Pauls Square
  " " - Fire investigation, Flooring Accessories
  " " - Fire invest. Thorobred Yarn power factor cubicle
  " " - Technical assistance ECNZ turbo-generator claim
  " " - Fire investigation, Akatarawa Rd house
Robins MBS - Technical advcie re lightning strike claim
  " " - Fire investigation, Orchard Street house
  " " - Fire investigation & reinstatement, bitumen plant
  " " - Fire investigation, General Assembly Library fire
  " " - Investigation, WCC sewage pump station flood
  " " - Incident investigation, flood damage to cables
NZI - Fire investigation, house fire.
  " - Fire investigation, yacht at Picton
  " - Fire investigation, Canterbury Regional Council

 

1991
Robins MBS - Fire investigation, Spa Pool.
Norwich Union - Fire investigation opinion.
Flinders Cook - Pump failure investigation.
  " " - Fire investigation, storage heater
Transpower - Haywards filter reactor fire

 

1990
Robins MBS - Fire investigation, BATs theatre.
  " " - Fire invest., Horman's Jewellers, Lwr Hutt.
  " " - Investigation/assist. with reinstatement, Pilkingtons Glass.
  " " - Fire investigation, spa pool.
  " " - Fire investigation, figure salon.
Gault Mitchell - Litigation re Tirohanga Rd (see * 1987).
Fire & Casualty - Fire investigation, photo autoprinter.
  " " " - Spa pool fire investigation
  " " " - Control panel damage investigation
NZI - Fire investigation, Cuba Mall.
Flinders Cook - Fire investigation, Newtown house.
  " " - Fire investigation, Expandite, Petone,
  " " - Fire investigation, Sar Street house.

 

1989
Robins MBS - Fire investigation, Drapery, Plimmerton.
  " " - Fire investigation, Butchers Upper Hutt.
  " " - Fire investigation, Office fire (heater).
  " " - Fire investigation, Kelvin Chambers (lights).
Robins MBS - Spa pool fire.
  " " - Fire investigation, Towbar Services.
  " " - Fire investigation, Russell & Somers (fan).
NZI - Fire investigation, Dairy, Adelaide Rd.
American Underwriters - Fire investigation, Cafe bar.
NZ Police -Expert witness Crown v DRG Canon
Brandon Brookfield/WCC - Arbitration between WCC/AESEC.

 

1988
MBS Chandler & Taylor - Investigation re pipe failure,
  WRC.
  " - Fire investigation, Williams & Adams (HP
  cleaner).
  " - Fire investigation, At the Bays restaurant.
Compair NZ Ltd. - Compressor failure investigation.

 

1987
Compair NZ Ltd. - Compressor failure investigation.
MBS Chandler & Taylor - House fire investigation,
  Tirohanga Rd. (*)
  " " - Fire investigation, Homestead Chicken.
  " " - Fire investigation, Haines hunter boat.
  " " - Fire investigation, Quality Inn.
Perry Castle - Expert opinion re fire.

1986
Wanganui Area Health Board - Generator problems
  investigation.
IBM - Computer standards investigation.
Kensington Swan - Expert witness re Guinness Street (see
  * in 1982)
Flinders Cook - Fire investigation, Giles & Elliott, Masterton.
MBS Chandler & Taylor - Fire invest., Grand Tavern.
  " " - Fire investigation, Performance Panel.
Sainsbury Logan Williams - Expert witness re Supergreen (see * in 1984).

 

1985
Chandler & Taylor - Fire invest., Veterinarian, Lwr Hutt.
  " " - Fire investigation, LV Martin store.
  " " - Fire investigation, Fish fryer.
  " " - Fire investigation, Tawa Meat Processors.
Flinders Cook - Fire investigation, NZI House air-conditioner.
  " " - House fire investigation, Masterton (dryer fire).
  " " - Fire investigation, Lunch bar.

 

1984
Chandler & Taylor - Fire investigation, Aro St shop.
  " " - House fire investigation, Pharazyn St.
  " " - Fire investigation, Big Save furniture.
  " " - Fire investigation, Supergreen. (*)
  " " - Spa pool fire, Tawa.
Flinders Cook - PDL heater fire investigation.
Caltex - Computer failure investigation.
TAB - Telephone betting terminals earthing problem.
Lawrence Associates - Fire investigation, dye factory.

1983
Chandler & Taylor - House fire investigation, Island Bay.
  " " - Quaypoint fire investigation.
  " " - PDL heater fire investigation.
  " " - Fire investigation, Woodspin Products
  (spraybooth).
  " " - Fire investigation, Mt. Cook Cafe.
  " " - Fire investigation, Zodiac Print." " - Fire investigation, Squirrel Smallgoods.
  " " - House fire investigation, Crieff St
  (switchboard).
Hanson & Burkett - Spa pool fire, Khandallah.
Flinders Cook - House fire investigation, Chatsworth Road (electric blanket)
  " " - Fire investigation, Windsor Engineering.
  " " - Switchboard fire, HV Drainage Board.
Philip Green - Motorcycle electrics investigation.
Church of Christ, Scientist - Fire investigation.

 

1982
Chandler & Taylor - House fire investigation, Guinness
  St. (*)
  " " - Fire investigation, Dairy, Riddiford St.
  " " - House fire investigation, Newlands.(TRS
  wiring)
  " " - Compressor failure investigation.
Brandons - Court appointed enquirer, Stafford v Environ
Ultrasound NZ Ltd. - Prospective arbitration.
NZ Electricity - Investigation into Hazardous Wiring
  Regulations.
Flinders Cook - Gear meat demolition fire.
  " " - Dixon Street flats hoist failure investigation.
NZ Insurance - Rectifier failure investigation.

 

1981
TAB - Telephone betting equipment compliance investigation.
Dalgety Shipping - Faulty portable generator
  investigation.
Chandler & Taylor - Haywards substation fault consequential loss claim.

 

Home , Company Profile , Services , Articles , Projects , Contact Us , Staff , Feedback

Site related questions or comments to webmaster@isp.co.nz